The short answer
Running is not a harder version of walking that everyone should graduate to, and walking is not a lesser option for people who cannot run. Both are excellent for health. The main differences are time, impact and what you enjoy.
If you have limited time and healthy joints, running packs more into each minute. If you want something you can do every day at any age, with little risk of injury, walking is hard to beat.
Estimated gross calories for a 70 kg adult on flat ground, from Compendium MET values. Per-kilometre costs stay close; per-hour costs do not.
| Activity | Speed | MET | Per hour | Per km |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Walking, moderate | 4.8 km/h (3 mph) | 3.5 | 257 kcal | 54 kcal |
| Walking, brisk | 5.6 km/h (3.5 mph) | 4.3 | 316 kcal | 56 kcal |
| Walking, fast | 6.4 km/h (4 mph) | 5.0 | 368 kcal | 57 kcal |
| Running, easy | 8 km/h (5 mph) | 8.3 | 610 kcal | 76 kcal |
| Running, steady | 9.7 km/h (6 mph) | 9.8 | 720 kcal | 74 kcal |
Health benefits
A large study by Paul Williams and Paul Thompson, published in 2013, compared about 33,000 runners with about 15,000 walkers over six years. When the energy people used was matched, walking and running produced similar reductions in the risk of high blood pressure, high cholesterol and diabetes, and walking did at least as well for heart disease risk.
Running has its own strong evidence. A study of more than 55,000 adults, published in 2014, found that runners had about a 30% lower risk of death from any cause and a 45% lower risk of death from heart disease than non-runners, even when they ran only 5 to 10 minutes a day at slow speeds.
Activity guidelines reflect the time difference. The World Health Organization counts a minute of vigorous activity, such as running, as roughly equal to two minutes of moderate activity, such as brisk walking: 75 to 150 minutes of running a week, or 150 to 300 minutes of brisk walking.
Joints and injuries
Each running stride lands with a force of about two to three times your body weight, compared with roughly one to one and a half times when walking. That extra load is why runners get more overuse injuries, such as shin pain, Achilles problems and runner's knee, than walkers do.
It does not mean running wears out healthy knees. A 2017 review of studies covering more than 100,000 people found hip and knee arthritis in 3.5% of recreational runners, compared with 10.2% of people who did not run and 13.3% of elite competitive runners. Moderate running appears to be fine, or even protective, for most joints.
If you already have joint pain, a past injury or are carrying a lot of extra weight, walking is usually the safer place to start.
This is general information, not medical advice. If you have a heart condition, joint problems or have not been active for a while, check with your doctor before starting to run.
Calories: per kilometre versus per hour
This is where much of the confusion lies. Per hour, running burns far more: around two to three times as much as walking at a moderate pace, because you are moving faster and working harder.
Per kilometre, the gap is smaller. Running burns roughly a third more per kilometre than walking, not double. So if you have an hour, running will use much more energy. If you have a set distance, such as a 5 km route, walking it still uses a good share of what running it would. The table shows estimates for a 70 kg adult.
When each fits
Neither suits everyone. These are the situations where one usually has the edge.
- Walk if you are starting from little or no activity.
- Walk if you have joint pain, a past injury or a lot of weight to lose.
- Walk if you want something you can do every day, including on recovery days.
- Walk if you want to talk with friends or family as you go, or fit activity into commutes and errands.
- Run if you are short of time and want the most benefit from each minute.
- Run if you want to improve fitness quickly, enjoy the challenge of races, or simply like it.
Mixing the two
You do not have to choose. Many runners walk on easy days, and many walkers add short bursts of jogging to build fitness. Walk-run intervals, such as 1 minute of jogging and 90 seconds of walking, repeated, are how programmes like the NHS Couch to 5K take people from not running at all to running 5 km in nine weeks.
Your step counter records steps either way, so daily totals keep counting whichever you choose. If you want to compare routes or sessions, a GPS-recorded walk or run gives the distance and time for each.