The short answer
Most modern step counters are accurate enough for what they are used for: tracking your own activity from day to day. In a controlled treadmill test published in JAMA in 2015, smartphone apps came within about 7% of the true step count, while some wrist devices undercounted by up to about 23%. Other studies have found that accuracy drops at slow walking speeds for most devices.
So a difference of a few hundred steps between your phone and watch, or between you and a friend on the same walk, is normal. Larger gaps usually have a simple cause.
How step counters work
Phones and watches contain an accelerometer, a tiny sensor that measures movement in three directions. When you walk, each footstep produces a small, regular bump in the readings. Software looks for that rhythm and counts each bump as a step.
To avoid counting random jolts, most step counters wait until they see several steps in a row before they start counting, then add those first steps back in. That is why a few steps across a room may not register at all. Many phones also have a low-power motion chip that counts steps all day without draining the battery.
The software is a set of trade-offs. Make it too sensitive, and it counts bumpy bus rides. Make it too strict, and it misses slow shuffling steps. Each manufacturer makes those choices differently.
Why your phone and watch differ
Your phone isn't always with you
Steps taken while it charges, sits on a desk or stays in a bag on the floor are not counted. A watch on your wrist catches them.
Your wrist isn't always moving
Pushing a pram, a trolley or a bike, or carrying shopping, keeps your arm still and can cause a watch to miss steps.
Your wrist moves without walking
Cooking, folding laundry, clapping or gesturing can add a few false steps on a watch.
Vehicles can add steps
Bumpy roads and some train journeys occasionally register as walking on either device.
Slow walking is harder to read
Very slow steps produce weaker signals, so most devices undercount at slow speeds.
Where you carry your phone
A phone held close to your hips counts most reliably, because that is where the walking rhythm is clearest. A front or back trouser pocket works best. A loose jacket pocket, a swinging handbag or a backpack weakens the signal. Holding the phone in your hand while you read or type often cuts the count, because your arm stops swinging naturally.
Consistency matters more than perfection. Carrying the phone in the same place each day makes day-to-day comparisons fair, even if the absolute number is a little off.
Why two apps disagree
If two apps on the same phone show different numbers, they are usually reading different things.
Different sources
One app may read only the phone's sensor, another may read your watch, and another may combine both.
Different merging
On iPhone, Apple Health collects steps from the phone, a watch and any other connected apps, and uses a priority order to avoid counting the same steps twice. On Android, Health Connect lets you set which app's steps take priority. An app that does its own counting, outside these, can disagree with both.
Sync timing
Watch data reaches the phone in batches, so one app may be minutes or hours behind another.
Day boundaries
Travelling between time zones, or a late-night walk, can land steps on different days in different apps.
Manual entries
Steps added by hand in one app may or may not appear in another.
Tips for a consistent count
WakaBuddy reads steps from the phone's own step counter, or from a watch through Apple Health on iPhone and Health Connect on Android. If its count looks off, checking which sources those apps hold is the best place to start.
- Pick one main source, phone or watch, and stick with it, especially during a challenge.
- Set the source order in Apple Health or Health Connect so the device you trust most comes first.
- Carry your phone in the same place each day, ideally a trouser pocket.
- Wear your watch on the wrist you told it to expect. Many watches ask which wrist you use and adjust for it.
- Keep your height up to date in your phone's health settings, as it affects distance estimates.
- Test it. Count 500 steps in your head on a steady walk and compare with your device. Within 5 to 10% is good.
- Compare weekly averages, not single days.