Why challenges work
A bit of friendly competition gives daily walking a reason beyond willpower. In the STEP UP trial, published in JAMA Internal Medicine in 2019, adults who were placed in small teams with a game-like competition added the most steps of any group, roughly 900 a day more than people with no game elements. Groups based on support or collaboration also did better than the control group, though by less.
The lesson is not that competition suits everyone. It is that walking with other people, in some structured way, tends to keep more people walking for longer.
Pick a format
The format decides who has a chance of winning and how people feel by the end. Choose one that fits your group.
Total steps
Simple and familiar. It favours people who already walk a lot and those with active jobs, so it works best among friends of similar fitness.
Total distance
Fairer between tall and short walkers, since taller people take fewer steps per kilometre. It needs reliable distance, so GPS-recorded walks or consistent devices help.
Days at goal
Everyone sets a daily target, and the winner is whoever hits theirs on the most days. It rewards consistency, and a beginner aiming for 5,000 steps can beat a runner aiming for 15,000.
Recorded walks
Count the number or length of deliberate walks rather than every step. Good for groups that want to build a walking habit specifically.
Team totals
Split into teams and add up steps or distance. This takes pressure off individuals and suits workplaces and families.
Choose the length and the rules
One week is a good trial run. Two to four weeks is the sweet spot for most groups: long enough to build a habit, short enough that people stay interested. Monthly challenges suit groups who already walk regularly.
Write down the basics before you start so there are no arguments later.
- Start and end dates, and which time zone counts, if people live in different countries.
- What counts: all steps, or only walks; whether running counts.
- Which devices and apps are allowed, and whether manual entries are.
- Any daily cap, for example only the first 20,000 steps a day count, to stop one marathon day deciding everything.
- What happens if someone is ill or away.
Keep it fair
Step counts vary between devices. A watch counts arm movements and is always on, while a phone misses every step taken while it sits on a desk. Someone pushing a pram or a supermarket trolley may lose steps on a watch because their wrist barely moves.
You will never make it perfect, but you can make it fair enough.
- Encourage everyone to use the same kind of device for the whole challenge, and the same pocket or wrist each day.
- Use days at goal or personal targets for mixed groups of age, fitness or health.
- For workplaces, offer a minutes-based option for people who use a wheelchair or have conditions that make step counts meaningless.
- Agree that obvious gaming, such as a phone tied to a ceiling fan, is out. Most groups find a light rule is enough.
Keep it friendly
The aim is more people walking, not a winner and a lot of people who feel bad. A few habits help.
- Talk in a group chat. Photos of routes and short updates keep people engaged far more than a leaderboard alone.
- Celebrate effort. Shout out the biggest improvement, the longest streak or the best photo, as well as the top total.
- Keep prizes small, or skip them. Bragging rights, choosing the next route or a shared meal usually work better than money.
- At work, keep it optional and private by default. Do not post everyone's numbers without their agreement, and avoid anything that feels like a performance measure.
Keep it going
Most challenges fade because nothing follows them. Start the next round within a week, change the format now and then, and let a different person choose the rules. Rolling weekly boards, where everyone starts fresh each Monday, keep things moving without a big launch each time.
How WakaBuddy does it
WakaBuddy reads steps from each person's phone or watch through Apple Health or Health Connect. Friends see each other on a shared board, groups have their own chat, and challenges can be set by steps, distance or recorded walks. Weekly leagues give a fresh start every week, and there is a monthly community challenge for anyone who wants a bigger field.